cc: Keith Briffa <k.briffa@uea.ac.uk>, "Ricardo Villalba" <ricardo@lab.cricyt.edu.ar>, Eystein Jansen <eystein.jansen@geo.uib.no>, edwardcook <drdendro@ldeo.columbia.edu>
date: Mon, 18 Jul 2005 07:07:10 -0400
from: edwardcook <drdendro@ldeo.columbia.edu>
subject: Re: the regional section and MWP Figure
to: Jonathan Overpeck <jto@u.arizona.edu>

<x-flowed>
Given the nature of the SH and what Ricardo put together, I would keep 
the Australian and South Aftrican borehole records separate. Henry 
Pollack can provide them, I am sure. He gave an excellent talk at a 
meeting in Canberra that I recently participated in.

Cheers,

Ed

P.S. Ricardo, here is the Oroko temperature reconstruction.

JANUARY-MARCH TEMPERATURES RECONSTRUCTED FROM
OROKO SWAMP, NEW ZEALAND SILVER PINE TREE RINGS
BE ADVISED THAT THE DATA AFTER 1958 ARE INSTRUMENTAL
TEMPERATURES
  YEAR  TEMP C
   900  13.751
   901  14.461
   902  13.236
   903  13.331
   904  13.483
   905  13.632
   906  12.959
   907  13.628
   908  13.372
   909  12.868
   910  13.244
   911  13.793
   912  14.048
   913  14.444
   914  13.095
   915  14.036
   916  13.215
   917  13.698
   918  13.570
   919  13.665
   920  13.871
   921  13.966
   922  14.762
   923  14.325
   924  14.077
   925  14.713
   926  14.081
   927  14.218
   928  13.793
   929  14.151
   930  14.985
   931  13.599
   932  14.663
   933  14.110
   934  14.968
   935  14.391
   936  15.484
   937  15.554
   938  14.977
   939  15.303
   940  15.179
   941  15.591
   942  14.737
   943  14.007
   944  14.865
   945  14.449
   946  14.350
   947  15.096
   948  15.257
   949  15.789
   950  15.303
   951  15.513
   952  16.111
   953  15.723
   954  15.459
   955  14.015
   956  13.083
   957  13.850
   958  14.069
   959  13.772
   960  14.873
   961  14.692
   962  14.923
   963  14.527
   964  15.034
   965  14.688
   966  14.486
   967  14.444
   968  14.436
   969  13.776
   970  13.809
   971  14.391
   972  13.487
   973  13.995
   974  14.061
   975  14.321
   976  14.882
   977  14.226
   978  14.977
   979  15.447
   980  14.424
   981  14.923
   982  14.180
   983  15.484
   984  13.487
   985  14.168
   986  14.176
   987  15.699
   988  15.187
   989  16.305
   990  14.845
   991  14.647
   992  15.765
   993  14.754
   994  14.271
   995  13.623
   996  14.300
   997  13.937
   998  14.040
   999  14.011
  1000  12.976
  1001  13.904
  1002  13.500
  1003  13.586
  1004  14.090
  1005  13.809
  1006  13.413
  1007  13.318
  1008  13.892
  1009  14.151
  1010  14.391
  1011  13.793
  1012  14.626
  1013  13.755
  1014  13.838
  1015  13.017
  1016  13.083
  1017  13.549
  1018  13.471
  1019  13.087
  1020  13.458
  1021  13.203
  1022  14.090
  1023  13.574
  1024  13.755
  1025  13.826
  1026  13.137
  1027  13.194
  1028  14.036
  1029  13.091
  1030  13.768
  1031  13.813
  1032  13.846
  1033  13.871
  1034  14.255
  1035  14.370
  1036  13.805
  1037  14.576
  1038  13.504
  1039  13.867
  1040  14.927
  1041  14.420
  1042  15.661
  1043  15.484
  1044  15.595
  1045  14.741
  1046  13.644
  1047  14.271
  1048  14.288
  1049  13.661
  1050  13.665
  1051  13.298
  1052  14.003
  1053  13.826
  1054  13.788
  1055  13.768
  1056  12.976
  1057  13.397
  1058  13.529
  1059  13.549
  1060  13.846
  1061  14.032
  1062  14.820
  1063  13.962
  1064  14.279
  1065  14.151
  1066  14.358
  1067  14.131
  1068  13.652
  1069  13.941
  1070  14.007
  1071  14.403
  1072  13.764
  1073  13.982
  1074  13.846
  1075  13.830
  1076  13.450
  1077  13.632
  1078  13.265
  1079  13.331
  1080  14.267
  1081  13.644
  1082  13.549
  1083  13.557
  1084  13.549
  1085  14.725
  1086  13.479
  1087  12.848
  1088  12.559
  1089  12.926
  1090  13.793
  1091  14.387
  1092  14.531
  1093  14.114
  1094  14.754
  1095  14.688
  1096  14.845
  1097  14.729
  1098  15.059
  1099  15.059
  1100  15.055
  1101  16.057
  1102  15.208
  1103  15.492
  1104  14.519
  1105  14.741
  1106  14.151
  1107  15.005
  1108  13.640
  1109  13.652
  1110  13.566
  1111  13.978
  1112  14.424
  1113  14.180
  1114  14.931
  1115  14.601
  1116  14.403
  1117  14.391
  1118  14.981
  1119  15.125
  1120  13.817
  1121  12.897
  1122  13.863
  1123  14.271
  1124  14.857
  1125  14.882
  1126  14.762
  1127  14.548
  1128  14.403
  1129  14.667
  1130  14.572
  1131  14.057
  1132  14.556
  1133  15.018
  1134  13.892
  1135  13.995
  1136  13.982
  1137  14.853
  1138  14.779
  1139  15.129
  1140  15.117
  1141  14.849
  1142  15.228
  1143  15.216
  1144  15.030
  1145  14.428
  1146  15.063
  1147  15.216
  1148  15.043
  1149  15.034
  1150  14.370
  1151  15.096
  1152  15.410
  1153  15.719
  1154  16.577
  1155  15.769
  1156  15.364
  1157  15.855
  1158  15.422
  1159  14.515
  1160  15.810
  1161  15.628
  1162  15.402
  1163  15.092
  1164  15.298
  1165  14.865
  1166  14.882
  1167  15.274
  1168  14.605
  1169  14.746
  1170  15.472
  1171  15.509
  1172  15.018
  1173  15.369
  1174  15.084
  1175  15.855
  1176  14.795
  1177  15.571
  1178  14.255
  1179  14.510
  1180  14.865
  1181  14.036
  1182  14.688
  1183  14.713
  1184  14.519
  1185  14.255
  1186  15.204
  1187  14.461
  1188  15.476
  1189  14.882
  1190  15.005
  1191  14.453
  1192  14.729
  1193  15.265
  1194  14.444
  1195  14.696
  1196  15.793
  1197  14.581
  1198  15.014
  1199  14.539
  1200  14.044
  1201  14.733
  1202  14.853
  1203  15.298
  1204  13.772
  1205  13.991
  1206  14.651
  1207  14.836
  1208  14.440
  1209  15.162
  1210  14.766
  1211  15.010
  1212  15.356
  1213  14.787
  1214  15.645
  1215  15.435
  1216  15.043
  1217  15.063
  1218  14.151
  1219  15.397
  1220  15.154
  1221  15.892
  1222  15.488
  1223  15.938
  1224  15.525
  1225  15.591
  1226  14.589
  1227  15.496
  1228  15.963
  1229  14.502
  1230  14.457
  1231  15.468
  1232  14.985
  1233  15.282
  1234  14.989
  1235  15.237
  1236  15.711
  1237  15.888
  1238  14.259
  1239  14.560
  1240  15.711
  1241  15.195
  1242  15.484
  1243  15.166
  1244  16.020
  1245  16.454
  1246  15.480
  1247  15.492
  1248  16.528
  1249  15.150
  1250  14.436
  1251  14.878
  1252  15.723
  1253  15.043
  1254  15.121
  1255  14.845
  1256  14.807
  1257  14.482
  1258  14.585
  1259  15.307
  1260  15.100
  1261  14.354
  1262  13.995
  1263  14.106
  1264  14.403
  1265  14.754
  1266  14.581
  1267  14.799
  1268  14.378
  1269  14.671
  1270  14.193
  1271  14.387
  1272  14.453
  1273  14.510
  1274  15.187
  1275  15.393
  1276  14.498
  1277  14.560
  1278  15.022
  1279  14.498
  1280  14.725
  1281  13.549
  1282  14.977
  1283  14.065
  1284  14.024
  1285  13.603
  1286  15.220
  1287  15.080
  1288  14.898
  1289  14.774
  1290  15.542
  1291  15.212
  1292  14.267
  1293  14.692
  1294  13.644
  1295  14.222
  1296  15.038
  1297  14.721
  1298  15.682
  1299  13.896
  1300  14.766
  1301  14.836
  1302  14.370
  1303  14.812
  1304  14.812
  1305  13.673
  1306  14.036
  1307  13.929
  1308  14.807
  1309  14.114
  1310  13.446
  1311  13.368
  1312  14.168
  1313  14.989
  1314  14.292
  1315  14.985
  1316  14.123
  1317  14.321
  1318  13.966
  1319  14.325
  1320  14.647
  1321  14.622
  1322  14.279
  1323  14.510
  1324  13.689
  1325  13.450
  1326  14.197
  1327  13.867
  1328  14.205
  1329  14.779
  1330  14.350
  1331  14.729
  1332  13.479
  1333  13.974
  1334  14.453
  1335  14.535
  1336  15.402
  1337  14.424
  1338  14.399
  1339  14.906
  1340  15.430
  1341  14.531
  1342  15.785
  1343  15.513
  1344  15.220
  1345  15.352
  1346  15.443
  1347  15.410
  1348  15.777
  1349  14.902
  1350  14.576
  1351  14.605
  1352  14.168
  1353  14.601
  1354  15.414
  1355  14.300
  1356  14.630
  1357  15.170
  1358  14.919
  1359  14.688
  1360  14.081
  1361  14.799
  1362  14.581
  1363  15.133
  1364  13.838
  1365  14.708
  1366  13.149
  1367  13.281
  1368  13.760
  1369  14.123
  1370  13.314
  1371  14.523
  1372  14.267
  1373  14.226
  1374  14.044
  1375  14.271
  1376  15.307
  1377  14.684
  1378  14.168
  1379  14.473
  1380  13.578
  1381  13.586
  1382  13.999
  1383  13.991
  1384  13.710
  1385  14.411
  1386  13.867
  1387  14.255
  1388  13.611
  1389  13.974
  1390  13.916
  1391  13.615
  1392  14.440
  1393  14.787
  1394  15.880
  1395  16.297
  1396  16.289
  1397  15.170
  1398  16.082
  1399  15.463
  1400  14.366
  1401  14.758
  1402  14.902
  1403  14.568
  1404  15.158
  1405  15.579
  1406  13.966
  1407  13.970
  1408  13.772
  1409  14.523
  1410  14.498
  1411  14.791
  1412  14.007
  1413  15.818
  1414  13.974
  1415  13.776
  1416  13.760
  1417  14.407
  1418  14.498
  1419  14.515
  1420  14.341
  1421  14.374
  1422  13.677
  1423  14.354
  1424  13.223
  1425  13.801
  1426  14.560
  1427  14.374
  1428  14.494
  1429  15.051
  1430  14.836
  1431  13.999
  1432  14.341
  1433  14.865
  1434  15.063
  1435  15.311
  1436  15.765
  1437  15.789
  1438  15.204
  1439  15.298
  1440  15.257
  1441  15.443
  1442  14.737
  1443  15.385
  1444  15.723
  1445  14.717
  1446  15.088
  1447  15.253
  1448  14.477
  1449  16.004
  1450  14.581
  1451  14.449
  1452  14.993
  1453  14.151
  1454  14.556
  1455  14.366
  1456  14.601
  1457  13.813
  1458  14.242
  1459  15.047
  1460  14.919
  1461  14.300
  1462  15.010
  1463  14.139
  1464  15.001
  1465  14.873
  1466  15.406
  1467  14.399
  1468  14.671
  1469  15.092
  1470  14.337
  1471  14.948
  1472  15.047
  1473  14.523
  1474  14.680
  1475  14.395
  1476  15.661
  1477  15.158
  1478  15.414
  1479  15.641
  1480  15.909
  1481  15.748
  1482  14.708
  1483  14.981
  1484  14.659
  1485  15.113
  1486  14.754
  1487  15.740
  1488  15.327
  1489  15.125
  1490  15.026
  1491  15.567
  1492  15.265
  1493  15.996
  1494  16.326
  1495  14.915
  1496  15.831
  1497  14.845
  1498  15.670
  1499  16.156
  1500  15.864
  1501  15.831
  1502  16.581
  1503  15.212
  1504  15.534
  1505  15.270
  1506  15.492
  1507  15.633
  1508  14.420
  1509  15.723
  1510  14.816
  1511  15.282
  1512  15.641
  1513  14.655
  1514  14.510
  1515  13.508
  1516  14.172
  1517  14.251
  1518  13.628
  1519  13.698
  1520  13.405
  1521  13.920
  1522  13.974
  1523  13.978
  1524  14.238
  1525  14.003
  1526  13.298
  1527  13.694
  1528  15.005
  1529  14.218
  1530  14.110
  1531  14.593
  1532  13.916
  1533  14.510
  1534  14.057
  1535  14.048
  1536  13.673
  1537  14.477
  1538  14.090
  1539  14.300
  1540  14.374
  1541  14.387
  1542  14.085
  1543  14.184
  1544  14.597
  1545  14.783
  1546  15.348
  1547  15.859
  1548  15.835
  1549  14.729
  1550  15.451
  1551  15.204
  1552  15.022
  1553  15.352
  1554  14.251
  1555  14.135
  1556  14.609
  1557  14.572
  1558  15.224
  1559  14.688
  1560  14.618
  1561  15.179
  1562  14.399
  1563  14.873
  1564  13.652
  1565  13.958
  1566  15.595
  1567  14.898
  1568  13.595
  1569  14.019
  1570  15.030
  1571  15.228
  1572  15.241
  1573  16.355
  1574  14.865
  1575  14.923
  1576  15.542
  1577  15.162
  1578  14.956
  1579  15.657
  1580  15.208
  1581  15.208
  1582  15.166
  1583  14.473
  1584  14.052
  1585  14.213
  1586  14.568
  1587  14.762
  1588  14.288
  1589  14.069
  1590  13.929
  1591  13.479
  1592  14.044
  1593  14.267
  1594  14.288
  1595  14.609
  1596  14.362
  1597  13.846
  1598  14.098
  1599  14.147
  1600  14.783
  1601  13.995
  1602  13.925
  1603  13.999
  1604  14.688
  1605  13.892
  1606  15.410
  1607  14.325
  1608  15.241
  1609  15.104
  1610  14.531
  1611  15.958
  1612  14.597
  1613  14.337
  1614  14.647
  1615  13.318
  1616  14.424
  1617  13.768
  1618  14.779
  1619  14.886
  1620  14.065
  1621  14.085
  1622  14.626
  1623  13.912
  1624  13.487
  1625  14.292
  1626  13.075
  1627  13.871
  1628  13.850
  1629  13.755
  1630  14.680
  1631  14.048
  1632  14.601
  1633  15.752
  1634  14.420
  1635  14.085
  1636  14.230
  1637  15.426
  1638  16.322
  1639  14.762
  1640  14.882
  1641  14.985
  1642  14.931
  1643  15.484
  1644  15.843
  1645  14.861
  1646  14.284
  1647  14.494
  1648  14.935
  1649  13.966
  1650  14.296
  1651  13.768
  1652  15.001
  1653  14.944
  1654  15.418
  1655  15.146
  1656  14.915
  1657  14.803
  1658  14.638
  1659  14.630
  1660  14.052
  1661  13.702
  1662  14.081
  1663  14.312
  1664  14.197
  1665  13.780
  1666  14.292
  1667  14.634
  1668  13.768
  1669  14.671
  1670  14.246
  1671  14.812
  1672  15.216
  1673  15.810
  1674  14.869
  1675  16.148
  1676  14.977
  1677  14.923
  1678  15.488
  1679  14.956
  1680  14.098
  1681  14.523
  1682  15.327
  1683  15.666
  1684  15.554
  1685  15.270
  1686  15.492
  1687  15.459
  1688  14.754
  1689  14.741
  1690  14.700
  1691  14.906
  1692  13.904
  1693  14.527
  1694  15.063
  1695  14.399
  1696  15.096
  1697  15.360
  1698  15.694
  1699  15.249
  1700  14.779
  1701  14.609
  1702  15.336
  1703  15.121
  1704  15.154
  1705  15.212
  1706  14.750
  1707  15.472
  1708  14.164
  1709  13.665
  1710  14.213
  1711  14.741
  1712  15.521
  1713  15.410
  1714  14.519
  1715  15.154
  1716  14.597
  1717  15.212
  1718  14.688
  1719  13.962
  1720  15.109
  1721  15.839
  1722  15.765
  1723  15.001
  1724  15.389
  1725  15.088
  1726  14.655
  1727  14.312
  1728  14.824
  1729  14.981
  1730  13.640
  1731  15.043
  1732  13.953
  1733  13.681
  1734  14.036
  1735  13.937
  1736  14.832
  1737  14.807
  1738  14.325
  1739  14.337
  1740  14.680
  1741  14.779
  1742  14.255
  1743  14.205
  1744  14.024
  1745  14.069
  1746  15.216
  1747  15.455
  1748  15.447
  1749  15.851
  1750  15.253
  1751  14.626
  1752  15.294
  1753  15.744
  1754  15.158
  1755  14.750
  1756  15.319
  1757  15.059
  1758  15.195
  1759  14.725
  1760  14.609
  1761  14.869
  1762  15.212
  1763  15.505
  1764  14.634
  1765  15.175
  1766  14.552
  1767  15.109
  1768  14.312
  1769  14.090
  1770  14.246
  1771  14.127
  1772  14.667
  1773  14.312
  1774  14.659
  1775  14.296
  1776  14.527
  1777  14.069
  1778  15.005
  1779  14.832
  1780  15.146
  1781  14.865
  1782  14.102
  1783  13.735
  1784  14.510
  1785  14.052
  1786  14.795
  1787  15.455
  1788  15.298
  1789  14.325
  1790  14.927
  1791  14.230
  1792  14.230
  1793  14.836
  1794  15.637
  1795  15.022
  1796  14.473
  1797  14.968
  1798  14.028
  1799  13.463
  1800  14.151
  1801  15.187
  1802  15.290
  1803  15.732
  1804  14.985
  1805  15.224
  1806  16.251
  1807  13.289
  1808  14.420
  1809  14.696
  1810  14.568
  1811  15.802
  1812  16.082
  1813  16.416
  1814  16.082
  1815  16.309
  1816  15.967
  1817  16.247
  1818  15.208
  1819  15.587
  1820  15.323
  1821  15.505
  1822  14.812
  1823  15.298
  1824  15.022
  1825  15.179
  1826  15.967
  1827  14.040
  1828  14.449
  1829  14.242
  1830  14.548
  1831  14.378
  1832  15.137
  1833  13.496
  1834  14.081
  1835  15.228
  1836  14.700
  1837  14.432
  1838  14.927
  1839  14.482
  1840  15.175
  1841  14.296
  1842  14.762
  1843  14.350
  1844  14.770
  1845  15.026
  1846  14.688
  1847  14.944
  1848  15.088
  1849  14.774
  1850  14.865
  1851  14.787
  1852  14.527
  1853  14.502
  1854  15.183
  1855  14.828
  1856  15.270
  1857  14.436
  1858  14.721
  1859  14.539
  1860  14.407
  1861  14.832
  1862  14.271
  1863  14.490
  1864  13.953
  1865  15.290
  1866  14.473
  1867  15.414
  1868  14.440
  1869  15.129
  1870  15.022
  1871  15.468
  1872  14.993
  1873  14.890
  1874  14.638
  1875  14.898
  1876  14.993
  1877  14.366
  1878  14.333
  1879  13.454
  1880  15.369
  1881  15.109
  1882  15.187
  1883  15.278
  1884  14.308
  1885  15.026
  1886  15.385
  1887  15.183
  1888  14.127
  1889  14.985
  1890  15.480
  1891  14.717
  1892  15.773
  1893  14.807
  1894  15.451
  1895  15.179
  1896  13.780
  1897  14.531
  1898  13.912
  1899  14.354
  1900  15.290
  1901  15.752
  1902  14.886
  1903  15.216
  1904  15.938
  1905  15.208
  1906  14.279
  1907  14.923
  1908  15.022
  1909  15.501
  1910  15.633
  1911  15.212
  1912  13.648
  1913  14.329
  1914  15.389
  1915  14.704
  1916  15.983
  1917  14.779
  1918  14.432
  1919  14.024
  1920  14.040
  1921  14.622
  1922  15.315
  1923  14.560
  1924  15.835
  1925  14.927
  1926  14.812
  1927  15.220
  1928  16.433
  1929  14.506
  1930  14.535
  1931  14.073
  1932  14.440
  1933  15.406
  1934  14.708
  1935  15.026
  1936  14.106
  1937  13.372
  1938  14.663
  1939  13.842
  1940  13.879
  1941  14.725
  1942  14.510
  1943  14.337
  1944  15.133
  1945  14.189
  1946  14.048
  1947  14.098
  1948  14.923
  1949  14.733
  1950  14.581
  1951  15.121
  1952  14.073
  1953  14.572
  1954  14.106
  1955  14.457
  1956  14.849
  1957  14.626
  1958  15.374
  1959  15.183
  1960  14.970
  1961  15.140
  1962  15.289
  1963  14.991
  1964  14.395
  1965  14.991
  1966  15.587
  1967  14.948
  1968  14.948
  1969  14.629
  1970  15.779
  1971  16.354
  1972  15.247
  1973  14.671
  1974  15.353
  1975  16.141
  1976  14.586
  1977  14.863
  1978  15.332
  1979  14.948
  1980  14.906
  1981  15.481
  1982  14.991
  1983  14.117
  1984  15.353
  1985  15.225
  1986  15.587
  1987  15.140
  1988  14.863
  1989  16.098
  1990  15.417
  1991  14.991
  1992  14.096
  1993  14.160
  1994  15.183
  1995  15.119
  1996  15.630
  1997  14.927
  1998  15.417
  1999  16.354

On Jul 17, 2005, at 10:40 PM, Jonathan Overpeck wrote:

> Thanks Ricardo and Ed! I personally am not a big fan of the Jones and 
> Mann SH recon. It is based on so little. On the other hand, it is in 
> the literature. So, I leave it up to you and Keith to decide - perhaps 
> Eystein can weigh in too.
>
> I do, however, think it would be really helpful to included the 
> borehole data (see prev. emails) - either as a single SH curve, or 
> (probably better) two regional curves (Australia and S. Africa). Is 
> there a reason this is not a good idea? Can't complain about snow bias 
> down there...
>
> Thanks again - I look forward to seeing the next draft and figure - 
> complete w/ borehole I hope.
>
> thx, Peck
>
>> Hi Keith,
>>
>> Please, find attached my last version of the SH temp. As you know, Ed 
>> Cook
>> returned my original version of the SH with minor comments. Overall, 
>> he
>> agreed with the text. Still I am waiting from him the Oroco Swamp 
>> data to
>> include in the Figure, which first draft I sent you more than a month 
>> ago.
>>
>> In the last version I have included a first paragraph referring to 
>> the Jones
>> and Mann (2003) temperature reconstruction for the SH.  At that time 
>> we have
>> to decide if we want to have the hemispheric (Jones and Mann) and the
>> regional views (Tasmania, New Zealand, Patagonia, maybe include 
>> Antarctica
>> (Ommem et al. 2005)), or just one of them. If we decide to stay with 
>> the
>> hemispheric view, we should include Jones and Mann reconstruction at 
>> the
>> bottom of one of your figures. In cases that we decide to maintain 
>> both
>> hemispheric and regional views, we should include Jones and Mann at 
>> the
>> bottom of my figure.  Please, could you check with Peck and Eystein 
>> to see
>> the best way to proceed? Thanks,
>>
>> Ricardo
>>
>>
>>
>> ----- Original Message -----
>> From: "Keith Briffa" <k.briffa@uea.ac.uk>
>> To: <jto@u.arizona.edu>; "Eystein Jansen" <Eystein.Jansen@geo.uib.no>
>> Cc: <ricardo@lab.cricyt.edu.ar>; "Ed Cook" 
>> <drdendro@ldgo.columbia.edu>
>> Sent: Friday, July 15, 2005 11:01 AM
>> Subject: the regional section and MWP Figure
>>
>>
>>>  Guys
>>>  still need the SH temp bit from Ricardo/ED to edit and am exploring 
>>> the
>> MWP
>>>  Figure - but the concept still is unclear to me - but we agreed to 
>>> do a
>>>  plot like Tom's . The regional section is still a worry  - I am 
>>> happy to
>>>  very briefly edit the section on NAO (possibly incorporate the ENSO
>> stuff )
>>>  but my understanding is that this section is best done (to 
>>> incorporate
>> also
>>>  the regional moisture work of Ed ) by Ricardo /Ed with input my 
>>> Peck. This
>>>  is still my opinion. I also would appreciate feedback re the 
>>> regional
>>>  forcing section that I think we may have to drop - but perhaps not.
>>>  Therefore I ask that when i get the SH temp stuff I will 
>>> incorporate it
>> but
>>>  that you guys (Peck, Ricardo, Ed and Eystein interacting over the 
>>> North
>>>  Atlantic bit) first review and redo the regional section .
>>>  It is important to get feedback from Henry re the borehole stuff and
>>>  involve Tom in the debate with all of us , of the value of the 
>>> Figure . In
>>>  meantime , will experiment with the Figure and review existing text 
>>> and
>> bullets
>>>  Keith
>>>
>>>  Keith
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>>  --
>>>  Professor Keith Briffa,
>>>  Climatic Research Unit
>>>  University of East Anglia
>>>  Norwich, NR4 7TJ, U.K.
>>>
>>>  Phone: +44-1603-593909
>>>  Fax: +44-1603-507784
>>>
>>>  http://www.cru.uea.ac.uk/cru/people/briffa/
>>>
>>>
>>>
>>
>> Attachment converted: Macintosh HD:Southern hemisphere2.doc 
>> (WDBN/IC) (0008A6E0)
>
>
> -- 
> Jonathan T. Overpeck
> Director, Institute for the Study of Planet Earth
> Professor, Department of Geosciences
> Professor, Department of Atmospheric Sciences
>
> Mail and Fedex Address:
>
> Institute for the Study of Planet Earth
> 715 N. Park Ave. 2nd Floor
> University of Arizona
> Tucson, AZ 85721
> direct tel: +1 520 622-9065
> fax: +1 520 792-8795
> http://www.geo.arizona.edu/
> http://www.ispe.arizona.edu/
>
>
==================================
Dr. Edward R. Cook
Doherty Senior Scholar and
Director, Tree-Ring Laboratory
Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory
Palisades, New York 10964  USA
Email:	drdendro@ldeo.columbia.edu
Phone:	845-365-8618
Fax:	845-365-8152
==================================

</x-flowed>
